Introducing Star City Games Ship + Sell Program!

Selling your extra Magic: The Gathering cards has never been this fast or easy!

Have a bunch of cards to sell but no time to submit a buylist order? Introducing Star City Games Ship + Sell!

1. Fill Out The Brief Form

Once you’ve filled out the form, you’ll get confirmation to ship your cards in minutes!

2. Ship Your Cards

Once you receive your confirmation email, safely and securely ship your cards to:

ATTN: Ship + Sell

Star City Games

5728 Williamson Rd NW

Roanoke, VA 24012

We’ll send you an initial follow up email to confirm we received your cards and begin processing your shipment at that time. An additional follow-up email containing an offer will be sent to you once processing concludes.

3. Get Paid!

When you accept our offer, we’ll issue your payment using the method of your choice.

Shipments containing less than 1,000 cards will be fully processed within four (4) business days. Every additional 1,000 cards will require one (1) additional processing day



When should I expect to receive my offer?

An offer will be emailed to you as soon as we finish processing your collection, typically within four (4) business days from when we receive your cards.

I’ve accepted the offer. When do I get paid?

Once you’ve accepted our offer and confirmed your preferred payment method:

  • PayPal and Store Credit payments will be issued within one (1) business day
  • Checks will be issued within three (3) business days

Can you provide me a list of all of the cards I sent you?

Using the Ship + Sell program, we are unable to provide an itemized list of cards, grades, or prices. If you are interested in receiving such, please submit your sell order via our buylist page.

What cards can I sell?

We buy all Magic: The Gathering cards. Pricing will be completed on the same day we process your shipment, and any cards without individual prices will be purchased at the bulk rates that appear on our buylist.


Anything I should know before I ship my cards?

We recommend you securely pack your cards into something that limits movement, like an old deckbox or plastic card case. For larger collections, you may want to use something to take up extra space.

If our team needs to remove cards from sleeves and/or binders, please note that having to do so may increase the timeframes noted above.

Who pays for shipping?

The seller is responsible for any shipping expenses, fees, duties, or customs when shipping cards to us.

I’ve shipped my cards to you. Now what?

As long as your shipment was properly labeled, we’ll contact you as soon as it is received. Please note that improper labeling may delay us from doing so.

What happens if I decline the price you offer for my cards?

If you’re unhappy with our offer, and live within the continental United States, we will return your cards to you at our expense.

If you live outside of the continental United States we will pay 25% of the return shipping costs. The seller will be responsible for any shipping-related costs beyond that