The design of this deck comes from my ongoing project to create a deck of each of the 27 possible color combinations. I had an Isperia deck designed for me by some of the nice folks over at MTGS, but it really wasn’t my styleâ€”far too passive and reactive. Additionally, I like the commander to be a significant part of the deck, and Isperia’s relatively high casting cost kept that from happening, so I decided to move the curve in the direction of our favorite Spirit.

This is the lucky thirteenth deck of the project (and my 18th deck in total). If you’re keeping score at home, here’s the lineup so far:

Jund: Kresh the Bloodbraided (also Adun Oakenshield and Karrthus, Tyrant of Jund)
Esper: Merieke Ri Berit
Bant: Phelddagrif
Grixis: Thraximundar (also Lord of Tresserhorn)
Naya: Rith, the Awakener
RUG: Intet, the Dreamer (also Animar, Soul of Elements)
R/W/U: Ruhan of the Fomori
W/B/R: Oros, the Avenger
W/B/G: Karador, Ghost Chieftain
BUG: The Mimeoplasm (also Vorosh, the Hunter)
White-Blue: Geist of Saint Traft
Black-Green: Nath of the Gilt-Leaf
White: Isamaru, Hound of Konda

That leaves Five-Color, White-Black, White-Red, White-Green, Blue-Black, Blue-Red, Blue-Green, Black-Red, Red-Green, Blue, Black, Red, Green, and Artifact still to be made.

Many of the thoughts you’ll read here are stream of consciousness as I was thinking about the deck and looking up cards. This one might be a little choppier than a normal article, but it’s also more organic and shows not just what I was thinking but how I was thinking. This seems like a useful insight to both deckbuilders and critics (in the positive sense of the word). If it’s a good line of reasoning, you can replicate the success. If it goes sideways, you can point it out to me so I can course-correct and you avoid it yourself.

Geist doesn’t much suggest a strategy (more on that in a moment), so I ran with the idea of "What do I want this deck to do?" instead of "What do I want to put into the deck?" The latter is fine when you have a Commander that makes a clear statement, like Kresh or Thraximundar, but I think Geist is far less clear. You could go with the obvious Spirits deck, or a slightly less obvious idea of an Angel theme, or maybe run the "everything has hexproof" idea. Tribal is a little overdone (although I do still want an Angels deck despite the fact that it seems silly to run one of the best, Restoration Angel, in it), so I wanted to avoid that.

So I gave up and played some Skyrim. Nothing clarifies the thought process better than a little Smithing.

After a few more steps along my path towards the ability to create Dragon Armor, I turned back to thinking about what I want to do with the Geist. I started visualizing what games would look like with me always playing it on turn 3. That means being moderately aggressive or at least getting into the Red Zone frequently. It’s certainly not Kaalia of the Vast aggressive, but it does mean attacking.

The first question I asked myself is if I could do anything with the token after it deals damage but before it goes away. While there are one or two things, it feels like I’d really need to shoehorn stuff in that might not be that valuable at other points in the game, so that got scrapped pretty quickly.

The second thing that came to mind was keeping alive the Geist. Since it’s really only going away to board wipes or sacrifice things (like Grave Pact), its main weaknesses are the fact that it doesn’t fly and its relatively low power and toughness. I decided to run with this a bit, and it led me to "getting general damage kills with a 2/2," which is far enough outside the box to be worth exploring in some depth. I can’t over-focus on this idea because Geist isn’t on its own good enough to do this (unlike, say, Uril the Miststalker or Karrthus, Tyrant of Jund). It needs plenty of support, and support means resources. Plus, I meanwhile have to keep from getting killed myself.

That last thought led me to some small measure of control. While I’m trying to rack up Geist damage, I have to prevent your guys from doing the same to me. We’ll put this on the back burner for the moment, since I have to decide how that’s going to manifest itself. Will it be some kind of counterspell strategy? Spot removal? Something that slows everyone else down? I know that Mirror Strike is a card that I want to playâ€”a card that will make people twitchy about attacking with something giantâ€”so I wrote that on the decklist right away.

Stuff About Making Geist Deal Damage

There are two ways to get Geist damage through. The first is making it larger, and the second is making it unblockable. Stylistically, I like the former rather than the latter, so that’s the direction I want to go, although I’ll probably eventually run some of both. The first card that occurred to me was a new one, Ajani, Caller of the Pride. Since one of the awesome things about this version of Ajani is that it comes back with Sun Titan, both of them got written on the list together. That Sun Titan will be able to target a number of things, like the bounce creatures we’ll mention later.

Steel of the Godhead fits the bill as something that both makes the Geist bigger and unblockable, so it’s perfect. I don’t play Swords of X and Y in too many decks, so I start looking down the list of those. I’m not worried about targeted removal because of the hexproof, which means I want to focus either on the effect the Sword(s) give(s) or the protection against the creatures it will face. I settle on Sword of War and Peace to punish greedy card-drawers, gain some life, and protect against damage-based sweepers such as Blasphemous Act.

I also go with the classic Sword of Fire and Ice for the same damage protection and the card draw. I pick Batterskull because it’s good on its own as well as a beating when equipped to the Geist and put Sword of Vengeance on the short list. With all these artifacts, I’d like something to fetch them, but I’ll have to use spells since Trinket Mage gets only the Sol Ring and Treasure Mage so far only gets Duplicant (and there’s not really a plan for much else in that direction, since we’re keeping mana costs low). I’ve never actually played with Tezzeret the Seeker, so I run with that plus Fabricate.

I think a small amount about things that definitely slow down the opponents, like Grand Arbiter Augustin IV, Spelltithe Enforcer, Loxodon Gatekeeper, and Kismet. I’m on the fence about them because they’re the types of things that will get you targeted, and I’m not sure this deck has enough real punch to deal with a whole table full of irritated opponents. I think I have to play a more subtle game, so those are out.

Mikaeus, the Lunarch might also provide some gas to Geist and other creatures, so we’ll give that a whirl. Sun Quan, Lord of Wu is just tech and might be the last bit to tip Geist over the top.

I want at least one more equipment that gives trample to the Geist, and I’m down to Loxodon Warhammer, which is nice and lifelink-y, and the crazily-technorific Vorrac Battlehorns (go ahead, I’ll wait while you look it up). Everyone plays Warhammer, so Battlehorns it is. That card is also going to find a home in my Animar deck.

Control

I decide that I want to keep the mana cost of things down. Despite the control-ish nature of the colors, I want to have stuff to do all the time, having available stuff to do both on my turns and others’. I think creating a situation where it’s difficult for others to keep too many creatures on the battlefield is pretty good, so I’m going to go with a bit of a bounce strategy. Cards like Equilibrium, Erratic Portal, and Crystal Shard come to mind. Then I’m going with the techiest of my techiness: Portcullis. Portcullis shuts down massive token creation strategies, and if I have the early drop guys, mine are the only ones that can be on the field until someone Wraths or deals with the Portcullis. There may also be some political advantage to the card. "Hey, I’m keeping the Rith player in check." I don’t necessarily want to go full Cloudstone Curio, but it’s at least on the table until I need cuts.

Bounce seems to lead to Blink. Deadeye Navigator is too good to not play, as is Restoration Angel. The fact that they’re relatively new cards and I haven’t really played them much makes them pretty attractive. I guess that also leads us to Venser, the Sojourner, which makes me run through the other white and blue planeswalkers. Tamiyo is pretty spicy, so we’ll put her on the list too.

Bounce and Blink point me toward Clone effects. The thing I like about this line is that I don’t have to necessarily hold the Clone waiting for someone to play their awesome thing. I can run it out earlier and then reset it to the awesome thing with Venser or the Restoration Angel. Duplicant is a natural fit. Although I play it in several other decks, it seems like not playing the same card over and over since it always imprints something different. Phyrexian Ingester is certainly the fatter cousin of Duplicant and deserves a spot. Cryptoplasm can do many things, and it can also come back with Sun Titan.

I have a fleeting thought of some janky Myojin of Cleansing Fire / proliferate combo, and fortunately the thought dies quickly on the vine. Speaking of jank, I also consider some kind of Isochron Scepter / Holy Day package, and that also quickly withers.

The deck’s colors could support Aether Adept over Man o’ War, but I think I’ll squeeze in both. Mistmeadow Witch seems to also support all these hijinks, so it’s in as well.

I’m going to run a few Wrath effects of my own. I think I have some kind of promo or foily Day of Judgment that I’ll run despite not being as good as Wrath of God (unless I put in some regenerators…) because it’s pimpy. Austere Command and Akroma’s Vengeance came to mind, but I think the former is better since I’m going to have a fair number of enchantments that I want to keep around. Rout has its charms as well, since it can be played as an instant.

You can’t do everything in a deck, but that doesn’t mean you can’t run a few answers to things. Return to Dust is one of the best cards in the format for dealing with stuff once so you don’t have to deal with it again. I wonder how good Seal of Cleansing might be.

While I’m in bounce-land, I think that both Hiberation and Wash Out have quite some application in battling against the hyper-aggressive green decks, especially with Hibernation being an Instant. I’d be careful playing Wash Out in a deck with more than two colors, since you’re pretty likely to run it into a color that you’d like to keep on the table.

I guess we can call Angelic Arbiter control, since it forces opponents to make a choice of whether to cast stuff or attack. It certainly shuts off Craterhoof Behemoth.

Ramp and Card Draw

W/U doesn’t have the same weapons in the arsenal that G/X does, so we have to do what we can. I’m not a fan of mana rocks, but there really isn’t much choice here after Land Tax, Knight of the White Orchid, and, of course, Solemn Simulacrum. Wayfarer’s Bauble is the Rampant Growth replacement for non-green decks. I think I’m going to try to use card draw as the ramp replacement here. It’ll be the first deck in which I play Future Sight since I took apart my original Phelddagrif deck back in like 2007. Sensei’s Divining Top should be able to take care of the top of the library a bit, getting the land situation a little more smoothed out.

Mulldrifter is a reasonable card draw creature, especially if there is Blinking and bouncing going on. I don’t want everything to be about the creatures (wouldn’t want to get completely shut down by Torpor Orb), so Blue Sun’s Zenith goes in.

I’m not sure if Cryptic Command goes in control or card draw, but it definitely goes in the 99. I’m not a fan of raw counterspells, needing something extra from them, so Overwhelming Intellect is a particularly good choice. At the six-land point, I’m pretty well established on the board, so countering a fatty plus drawing a handful is probably the right call. I considered Windfall here since I’m likely to dump most of my hand early, but without a way to actually take advantage of it (like with the off-color Underworld Dreams or something), I’m not a fan. Vanish into Memory is also some hybrid of control and card draw, so we’ll give that a whirl.

Other Creatures

The mix here is going to need to be other three- and four-drops which are good at laying on some pressure, perhaps taking some of the heat off of Geist, and then some larger late-game beaters. Mirror Entity comes to mind because it can in a mid-game suddenly make the Geist pretty dangerous. I don’t like that I can’t save it with Restoration Angel, but that’s not really a huge drawback. Despite how obscenely good they are, I’m avoiding Karmic Guide and Reveillark in this deck because I play them a good deal in the Karador deck, so I’d rather move in some other directions. If you’re going to use this list as a guide for your own, I’d heartily suggest both cards.

Silverblade Paladin seems like it could get interesting, especially Blinked out and returned to give double strike to something huge. Serra Ascendant feels a little cheesy, although not so much as to avoid it. Hero of Bladehold doesn’t need to be in a swarm deck to be good. Galepowder Mage is certainly on-theme, although I want to make sure that I’m not completely enslaving myself to the idea. Sakashima’s Student feels like there’s a good deal of play in it.

Wrapping It Up

At this point, there are 55 cards on the list. Being two colors, I think I can afford 37 lands, but given one of the colors isn’t green I think I’d like to go to 38 just to make sure I hit the land drops. That means only six more cards left. I think we’re okay on the control elements, so I’d like a little more card draw and a few more medium-to-large guys.

Kozilek is both of those, so he’s in, as is Consecrated Sphinx, although I have a feeling he’ll be one of the first cuts when I figure out something more interesting. I like Frost Titan for his ability to clear the path for the Geist. Elesh Norn helps as both creature control and making Geist bigger. I’d really like a Fog effect, and for one extra mana, Dawn Charm beats Holy Day. I’m going to make Sphinx of Uthuun the last pick since it has an enters-the-battlefield ability which involves getting cards and is a good-sized flier.

Lands

The land package on the decklist may be quite different than the lands I end up playing, mostly due to availability. A brother only has so many Tundras, after all. The significant land to me is Sejiri Steppe, which can get Geist through a traffic jam. This leads me to Soramaro, First to Dream, to be able to replay itâ€”so there’s a sufficient reason to get rid of Consecrated Sphinx. I think I’ll still be good on the card draw. I don’t want too many enters-the-battlefield tapped lands since I want to come out of the gate swinging. Although it’s perfectly legal to play Marsh Flats in this deck, I object stylistically, so the only fetch I’ll play is the one on both colors.

Here’s the list, which will probably end up with a change or two before it ever gets played because I’m sure there’s a few cards I won’t be able to dig up.

Geist of Saint Traft

Sheldon Menery

0th Place at Test deck on 08-19-2012

Commander

Creatures (29)

Planeswalkers (4)

Lands (38)

I’m heading to Gen Con as we speak to cover the World Magic Cup. It’s going to be a first-of-its-kind event, following up on the two-studio coverage we had in Barcelona. I’ll be in the booth with a cavalcade of stars such as Brian David-Marshall, Rich Hagon, Rashad Miller, Marshall Sutcliffe, and Zac Hill. Join us for all the coverage starting at 10:45 local time on Friday and stay tuned through what will prove to be an exciting weekend!

Geist Of Saint Traft