With Rivals of Ixalan right around the corner, it’s time to dust
off the card evaluation books and prepare to figure out how good each new
card is. So until I can get my hands dirty with the set, I’ll be taking a
crack at evaluating these fresh new cards. I know many players were
frustrated with Ixalan, so here’s to hoping that Rivals
changes it up a bit (although I like Ixalan just fine).
As always, when evaluating cards prior to playing with them, take it with a
grain of salt. These are my expectations, but context means a lot, and we
are lacking in that department at the moment. Without further ado, let’s
take a look at the new mechanic:
Ascend
Ascend is a mechanic that rewards you for having ten or more permanents.
It’s a little odd, as you can’t really interact with it, but there appear
to be plenty of cards with the mechanic.
Secrets of the Golden City is quite the interesting common. Divination is a
fine, yet unexciting Magic card. It’s not something you prioritize in
Limited, but it makes your deck some percentage of the time. One issue I
have with Secrets of the Golden City is the double-blue mana cost. You see,
one of the important aspects of Divination is the ability to cast it early
in order to hit your land drops. It’s not going to be so easy to do this
with Secrets of the Golden City. However, the upside of drawing three cards
instead of two if you have the City’s Blessing is quite powerful, so the
question is: how much better (or worse for that matter) is Secrets of the
Golden City in comparison to Divination?
I expect Secrets of the Golden City to be better than Divination, but not
by too much. I expect that many players will overrate this card. It’s not
going to be one of the top blue commons, but you’ll always be fine to put a
copy in your deck.
Lords
In a
recent article
by Ben Hayes, the Lead Game Designer for Rivals of Ixalan, he
mentions that this set is really going to hammer down on the tribal aspect
of the world. And luckily for us, this means that tribal lords are back!
Both of these cards are pretty great. Two mana for a bear with very
significant upside is always a card I’m happy to play. But how early are
you supposed to take these lords? My guess is that Legion Lieutenant is
going to be one of the best possible cards for the Vampire deck, as I
expect that archetype to focus on making tokens and going wide.
Merfolk Mistbinder, however, I don’t believe will be as good. Yes, it will
still be a great card in the Merfolk deck, but it will depend on how much
that archetype changes from where it was in Ixalan. Merfolk
focused on going tall with cards like River Herald’s Boon and One with the
Wind. Don’t get me wrong, you’ll still happily play the card, but it just
won’t have the same impact as the Vampire lord.
I believe Legion Lieutenant will be first pickable, but Merfolk Mistbinder
should probably be grabbed around pick 3-4 or so.
Undercosted Threats
I’ve always been a fan of cards like Bloodrage Brawler and Wanted
Scoundrels. They have a much better body for their cost, but come with a
relevant downside. Given how combat-oriented Limited is, this downside
rarely overrides the upside of an early aggressive body. These cards often
are disregarded by many early, but seem to overperform. And there are a
couple in this set.
Daring Buccaneer is better than you think it is. I mean, remember how
unbelievably good Kumena Speaker was? Sure, you need the Pirate in your
hand when you cast it, but that shouldn’t be a problem on turn 1. It’s a
Kumena Speaker that fits into two archetypes instead of one! In Ixalan, I would be content first picking a card like that. That
doesn’t necessarily mean it’s going to be that good in Rivals of Ixalan, but I find it hard to imagine the card should go
late in the draft.
Famished Paladin is a little harder to evaluate. The fact that it doesn’t
always untap is a pretty big liability, but given that the Vampire
archetype synergy is pretty much centered around lifelink, it also may
function like a 3/3 vigilance for two, which is quite the rate if you ask
me. I’m going to start out taking this card early because the ceiling is so
high, but I wouldn’t be surprised if it turned out not to be so great.
That’s it for today. If you have any cards you’re struggling to evaluate in
the set that have been previewed so far, feel free to inquire and I can
tackle it in my next article!